Standing Up To Male Gender Roles: Chivalry And Benevolent Sexism

aca58b5f321f687b0711368cd285e546-originaStart With Your Commute
 
By Jared Cline. Gender dynamics are often at play in our workplaces, homes, and communities—just about anywhere people are present. It should come as no surprise, then, that gender comes into play on the subway, and in quite striking ways.
 
Much has been made of the manspreader, although I won’t be discussing him at any length here. (For more on manspreading, read Cliff Leek’s blog, “3 Ways You Might Be Silencing Women (And a Checklist for Fixing That.”) I’d like to focus instead on the issue of offering up seats.
 
There are an established set of circumstances in which giving up a seat is expected. Public information signs on the subway proclaim that able-bodied men and women should give up their seats when pregnant, elderly, and disabled people are present. We can all agree on that.
 
But sometimes, women are included in this category. From time to time, I notice a man abdicate his seat for a woman, typically with a little flourish to ensure that his gesture doesn’t go unnoticed. Some might call this “chivalry” or “gentlemanly behavior.”
 
The timing of the act, however, tends to raise questions: What motivated him to give up his seat to that particular woman? Why not any of the other women standing nearby? What does that imply about how he views that woman? How might that make her feel? And what does it say about women, in general, that they are more deserving of a seat on the subway than a man?
 
An examination of the answers to these questions and their implications reveals a heterosexual, patriarchal power structure. This is why we increasingly see what at one time would have been a gesture of common courtesy going out of style. And yet there are many women who still expect men to fulfill these roles.
 
And why not? Sitting down is a momentary pleasure, and when someone sacrifices something of value for you, it can feel good. Additionally, you may connect this momentary pleasure with an affirmation of your cultural views—that is, seeing someone of the opposite gender act in accordance with traditional gender roles.
 
For men who want to support equality, this feeling among some women can be confusing. We men also like to sit down. Shouldn’t we be allowed to take a load off, as well?
 
A recent subway trip of mine saw these gender dynamics play out in an amusing way. I was riding next to a mother and her young daughter. After standing for some time, they were finally able to get a seat.
 
Turning to her daughter, the mother said, “That took so long. Men are supposed to give up their seats for women. That’s what men did when I was young.”
 
Her daughter, without missing a beat, responded, “Mom, you just like sitting down!”
 
What made the daughter’s view of the situation different from her mother’s? Aside from enjoyment at giving her mother a hard time, we can assume that unlike her mother, the daughter is not yet filled with arbitrary ideas about how men and women are supposed to act in relation to one another. She wouldn’t understand why a boy would give up a seat for her because 1) finders keepers and 2) she knows she’s perfectly capable of standing.
 
In the workplace, we often see men treating women with the same seemingly benevolent concern. But have we stopped to ask ourselves: what is the effect of not offering more stretch assignments to women? Why do we assume women with children wouldn’t want high-profile roles involving travel, when we hardly think about offering the same roles to men with children? Why do we think women are too fragile to hear critical feedback that may help them advance in their careers?
 
Working successfully with women means believing they can stand on their own two feet. So when you see men and women being treating differently at work and out in the world, don’t take it sitting down—or do!
 

f3c223e56ea53d74eb3dd4cda12dcbfb-huge-weJared Cline is the Community Manager of MARC (Men Advocating Real Change), an initiative of Catalyst. Get in touch if you have any questions about the community, would like to write a blog, or are looking for ways to collaborate. He can be reached at jcline@catalyst.org.


 
Posted by MARC Catalyst on Sep 20, 2017 9:03 AM America/New_York
LOG IN or JOIN MARC to Leave Comments

Blog Post Comments

Log in to post a comment.

This is a problem that I have given much thought - every time I see a lady carrying a heavy load or struggling a little.  Whilst I know I would help a gentleman in such a situation, I sometimes worry how it will be received if I do so for a lady.  I end up doing just the opposite of what I want - helping less - through a fear of misunderstanding and causing offence. I'd begrudgingly offer my seat on a train to an exhausted looking gentleman, but would give it a little more thought for a lady; so in my attempt to treat everybody equally - I fail.
  • Posted Tue 26 Sep 2017 12:00 PM EDT
Great comment Steven Williams‍! I've been in the same boat and I'm sure most guys feel the same. Ultimately, what I hear from women is that the main thing to ask yourself is: would I do the same thing for a man? If you know the answer is yes, then I think that can't help but spill over into your intentions and the subtle way those are conveyed. Thoughts?
  • Posted Wed 27 Sep 2017 11:15 AM EDT
I think there is a risk of overthinking kind or sensitive gestures that are "automatic" for an individual. For example, I automatically hold doors for just about anyone. I have never been called to task for it, but perhaps that is because there is no "flourish" or expectation that the gesture is acknowledged by the beneficiary.

I think intent and practice intersect here --- if you typically give up your subway seat when you are not tired and several women/men who look more tired get on the train, then don't worry about who takes offense or (perhaps more important) who takes the seat. If you meant it for the pregant woman or elderly man or tired student with a heavy bag and some young, able, well-heeled "jerk" jumps in the seat - let it go.
  • Posted Sun 08 Oct 2017 01:35 PM EDT

Polls

Has your company culture changed in the last several years?

Extremely
Very
Moderately
Slightly
Not at all

Mention Colleagues



Simply type “@” followed by the user’s name. After three letters, possible matches will appear. Select the desired username from the dropdown to @Mention them!

Questions? Visit our @Mentions tutorial for more.