Are You Riding The Glass Escalator?


 


"The glass escalator explains why men out-earn women, even in predominately female professions like nursing and teaching."




This week on Ask a Woman our guest expert, Professor Christine L. Williams, Chair of the University of Texas at Austin’s Sociology department, explores the phenomenon of the “glass escalator.” Dr. Williams studies gender, race, and class inequality in the workplace. She is the author of Inside Toyland: Working, Shopping, and Social Inequality (2006), which exposes how these forms of inequality are embedded within consumer culture through an examination of low-wage retail workers. She is currently studying the careers of women scientists in the oil and gas industry. Dr. Williams teaches courses on gender, sexualities, labor, and qualitative research methods. She recently published a study on gender and team structure, the results of which were detailed in an article put forth by Stanford University’s Gender Institute.

---
 
My team at work is made up of mostly women, and I've noticed that I've been getting greater visibility and praise than my equally skilled female teammates. How can I ensure that the women I work with get equal treatment?
 
This sounds like a classic case of the “glass escalator.” We have all heard of the “glass ceiling,” the hidden barriers that women face in male-dominated work settings. The glass escalator refers to the hidden advantages that accrue to men when they are in the minority. Stereotypes about masculinity, such as the beliefs that men are naturally more intelligent and make better leaders than women, tend to enhance men’s careers, whether or not they are in the minority. Consequently, men make more money than women do, even in predominately female professions like nursing and teaching.
 
The team structure provides additional hidden advantages to men. By the very nature of teamwork, the individual’s contribution to the final product is obscured. In order to achieve recognition and rewards for their contributions, individuals working on teams must be willing and able to stand out from the group and advertise their accomplishments. A number of studies suggest that this apparently gender-neutral requirement may be easier for men to fulfill than it is for women. Women may be regarded negatively when they promote themselves; they are more likely to be viewed as “aggressive” than “assertive.” Research also suggests that minority men and women who engage in self-promotion may be viewed negatively by their white colleagues and supervisors.
 
The answer is not more assertiveness training for minorities and women. Rather, teams should be required to identify objective and measureable standards for individual success. Those standards ideally should include at least some traits more commonly associated with women, such as being collaborative and empathic, so that women have a better chance of achieving the recognition and credit they deserve. 
Posted by Mike Otterman on Jan 25, 2013 10:41 AM America/New_York
LOG IN or JOIN MARC to Leave Comments

Blog Post Comments

Log in to post a comment.

Lars: I know of no evidence re the claim of unequal pay for the same work, and, believe me, I have asked many women who have made that claim. Now, Mike, Lars: if this were true, why would _anyone_ hire a man, when you can hire a woman to do the same work for ( allegedly) $.70 for every $1 a man makes? Here again, there is cherry-picking: the areas where women do poorly and are mistreated ( and there definitely are areas where women are mistreated) are brought up, but only areas in this categories are brought up. The areas of life where men get a raw deal are ignored: 90% of prison pop. is male; 90% of deaths on the job are male; a family-court system heavily-biased in favor of women; lack of reproductive rights for men; male teens dropping out of highschool at a higher rate than female teens, etc. Has anyone heard about the many false accusations of rape and violence against women that have ruined many men's lives? Why isn't there a provision in VAWA for false accusations leveled against men?. So all you hear all the time are the bad things done by big bad oppressor-wold man. So you believe what the radical feminists tell you. You never hear/read the full context.
  • Posted Fri 17 May 2013 08:07 PM EDT
Christine, why do you women accept lower salary the men even if you are doing the same job and having the same competence?
  • Posted Sat 09 Mar 2013 08:37 AM EST

Categories

Polls

Which masculine norm has been most challenging for you?

Avoid all things feminine
Be a winner
Show no chinks in the armor
Be a man's man

Mention Colleagues



Simply type “@” followed by the user’s name. After three letters, possible matches will appear. Select the desired username from the dropdown to @Mention them!

Questions? Visit our @Mentions tutorial for more.